Master Apollon House Gallery

Briefing Doc: The Madonna of Loreto by Caravaggio

---

Main Theme: Religious Realism and the Divine in Everyday Life

---

Key Ideas and Facts

Context

The Madonna of Loreto (also known as The Madonna of the Pilgrims) was commissioned in 1603 by the heirs of Marquis Ermete Cavalletti to decorate their family chapel in the Church of Sant’Agostino in Rome. The painting was intended to honor the Madonna of Loreto, a miraculous image revered in the sanctuary of Loreto.

Subject

The painting depicts the Virgin Mary, barefoot and holding the naked Child Jesus in a doorway. In front of her, two kneeling pilgrims, humble and weathered by life, adore her. This portrayal brings a sense of intimacy and accessibility, emphasizing the divine meeting the everyday.

Realism and Controversy

Upon its unveiling, The Madonna of Loreto caused a scandal due to its departure from traditional iconography. The Virgin Mary is presented not as an ethereal, idealized figure but as a relatable woman of the people, making her seem more human and approachable. The simple background and lack of ostentatious symbolism further reinforce the painting’s realist qualities. Giovanni Baglione, a rival of Caravaggio, recorded that the painting caused “a great uproar (schiamazzo)” among the people due to its unconventional depiction.

Light and Darkness

Caravaggio’s signature use of chiaroscuro—the contrast between light and shadow—intensifies the drama of the scene. The soft illumination of the pilgrims’ weathered faces and the humble figure of the Virgin highlights their poverty and reverence. In contrast, the shadowy background underscores the simple, unadorned nature of the scene, drawing focus to the sacred moment.

Source of Inspiration

The composition of Caravaggio’s painting might have been inspired by a 1574 engraving, The Adoration of the Magi, by his friend Cherubino Alberti, which was based on a design by Rosso Fiorentino. This influence is evident in the way the figures are arranged, creating a sense of immediacy and real-life emotion.

---

Quotes

• “[…] his project [for Caravaggio] was to give traditional motifs the immediacy of real life, rather than dignify the real with fragments of the classical. And once, there was a perfect confrontation between the two: this Madonna [of Loreto], leaning very elegantly against a pilaster with these two wrinkled plebeians, almost incongruously devout, adoring her. Compared to the pilgrims, the Madonna looks like wood; but perhaps she was supposed to look that way since the cult of the Madonna of Loreto was centered around a miraculous statue of the Virgin Mary which, like a benevolent female version of the Commander in Mozart’s Don Giovanni, was believed to come to life when venerated.”
  – Robert Hughes, art critic

---

Conclusion

The Madonna of Loreto is a quintessential example of Caravaggio’s style, capturing the sacred in an unvarnished, realistic manner. Through this work, Caravaggio sought to make religious figures more accessible to the common people, placing them in relatable, everyday contexts. The painting’s raw realism and break from traditional iconography caused controversy but also cemented Caravaggio as one of the most innovative and influential artists of his time.